"I love college football season. Saturdays, I'll literally just be at home watching college football," Olandria said on the show.

The pair had briefly explored a romantic connection during Casa Amor, and Olandria tells PEOPLE why she didn't "allow" herself "to feel that spark" with Nic "out of respect for Cierra," who he had been coupled up with and who she was friends with

The Peacock reality show, filmed in Fiji, offers a parallel America in which nearly naked contestants attempt to pair up and the audience votes on the winning couple.